Since my blog post and accompanying video demanding that Facebook change the way they treat their users and personal data, i received a video response from someone by the name of Rudy Arnauts who has turned this into a grassroots campaign, Meeting With Mark, to set up a face-to-face meeting with Facebook founder, Mark Zuckerberg. We're taking him up on his claims that Facebook is becoming more open, transparent, and democratic in how the site is governed. Of course, Facebook isn't the only offender, but it is probably the most prominent given it's popularity and reputation for this kind of abuse, so this may be a campaign for Facebook, but it could really have a ripple effect across the internet. Although Facebook is among the worst sites which actually exploit users for agreeing to their terms of service, most websites have very similar policies. In other words, just because they haven't done too much harm yet, doesn't mean they haven't reserved their right to. If you ask me, this meeting should be big, it should be streamed live, and there should be a live feed of viewers' comments.
From the channel: http://www.youtube.com/user/MeetingwithMark
The issue of disabled accounts is widespread as you can see for yourself by searching for terms like "facebook disabled" on not only Google, but also microblogging sites like Twitter, Facebook's help site forums, and even Facebook itself where you'll find dozens of groups with thousands of members all calling out for this to end. People all have important contacts, business relations, and other communication that is lost with their accounts. On top of that, the common practice for big websites is to only offer users a big FAQ style site along with forums for users to help each other, but no real contact with the company: Facebook users are Facebook's customer support.
Once upon a time, i was a loyal Facebook user, but now i'm in this not just to wake up Facebook, but to change the way our information is handled by sites across the web. Facebook has had this coming for a long time. Users don't seem to get angry until it happens to them. We can't blame everyone on the internet for being ignorant about this sort of thing, so we should raise awareness about it, and try to change it. If you want to help, please spread the word, make a video response, whatever-- just get the word out!
P.S. Isn't it time for a competent open source competitor to enter the arena?... =]
From the channel: http://www.youtube.com/user/MeetingwithMark
The issue of disabled accounts is widespread as you can see for yourself by searching for terms like "facebook disabled" on not only Google, but also microblogging sites like Twitter, Facebook's help site forums, and even Facebook itself where you'll find dozens of groups with thousands of members all calling out for this to end. People all have important contacts, business relations, and other communication that is lost with their accounts. On top of that, the common practice for big websites is to only offer users a big FAQ style site along with forums for users to help each other, but no real contact with the company: Facebook users are Facebook's customer support.
Once upon a time, i was a loyal Facebook user, but now i'm in this not just to wake up Facebook, but to change the way our information is handled by sites across the web. Facebook has had this coming for a long time. Users don't seem to get angry until it happens to them. We can't blame everyone on the internet for being ignorant about this sort of thing, so we should raise awareness about it, and try to change it. If you want to help, please spread the word, make a video response, whatever-- just get the word out!
P.S. Isn't it time for a competent open source competitor to enter the arena?... =]




7 comments:
I had a facebook account for a few months. After getting tagged in photos without permission, having who-knows-what scrawled on my wall and only seeing more and more similar issues arrising, I deleted my account. Or so I thought. I had to send a couple emails in to facebook's staff to get it actually delete (I hope it's deleted...).
I'm waiting for Google Wave to be open to the public. It will allow pretty much everything that facebook allows you to do, but you can run it on your own server, or the server of someone you trust and you KNOW it's secured and private.
Remember nexopia and myspace? All social networking site die eventually (myspace is basically a site for bands now). Hopefully Google Wave will finaly end facebook, but become more than a social site (email/IM replacement) and stay for a long time.
"P.S. Isn't it time for a competent open source competitor to enter the arena? =]"
Long overdue, IMO. I'm surprised that a real challenger hasn't arisen yet. Perhaps there is someone out there right now working on the very thing we're discussing? One can only hope......
There are some "open source" competitors, but none of them have what it would take to gain a critical mass of users. Let's see whether or not daisychain (http://daisycha.in) will...
Hey Anonymous
This is Rudy; the guy in the video above. Ironically I have been actually working on that very thing we are discussing. I see this disabling of my FB account as an almost surreal catalyst to the acceleration of that concept.
The longer this drags on, the more publicity this will get. It won't be too much longer til the mainstream media picks up on this.
When the competitors are as large as Facebook you need a complete paradigm shift to gain critical mass of users. Merely offering another social networking template that generates its revenues through bombarding its users with advertising will indeed never be able to go head to head with a giant like FB.
I believe we have that paradigm shift concept in social networking. What I need to concentrate on right now is making sure I have all of that in line for when this FB issue hits the mainstream media.
I honestly don't see any facebook replacement working unless there is two-way syncing with facebook and/or a way to be friends across the two networks.
I use facebook a lot and would be pretty upset if I was banned for no reason, but somehow I doubt even my usage is high enough to ever trigger some automatic triggers designed to prevent spam. Facebook is the only website that I still use despite not having a clear path to export any data I put in.
Luckily, everyone I know who has had their account disabled either (a) had a virus, (b) really was violating the TOS, or (c) got their account back.
Post a Comment